Skip To Content

Outcomes

We’ve listed recent Tribunal decisions and reasons below. The Tribunal publishes reasons for decisions on merits, penalty, motions and costs.

All reasons are also accessible and searchable on the Canadian Legal Information Institute’s (CanLII) website. CanLII does not charge for this service.

If you are looking for information about a physician not listed below or on the Upcoming Hearings page, go to Doctor Search on CPSO’s website.

How to read the table

  • Go to the Tribunal’s Glossary for definitions of commonly-used terms.
  • See our Guide to the Tribunal Process for more information about hearings and outcomes.
  • “Decision Reserved” means the hearing concluded, but the panel has not yet made its decision.
  • “CPSO Public Register” links to the physician’s public profile on CPSO’s website, which provides a summary of allegations and other details about the physician.
  • The CanLII website publishes the Tribunal’s reasons and those of other courts and tribunals. If there is no link to CanLII, the reasons are not yet released.

Date

Name

File

Details

Links

2022-11-23

Dr. Mark Trozzi

22-006

Motion Outcome:

Decision reserved

Details:

Jurisdictional and Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms Motion. Motions in the following matters will be heard together: Phillips, 21-023, Trozzi, 22-006, and Luchkiw, 22-012.

2022-11-23

Dr. Patrick Phillips

21-023

Motion Outcome:

Decision reserved

Details:

Rights and Freedoms Motion. Motions in the following matters will be heard together: Phillips, 21-023, Trozzi, 22-006, and Luchkiw, 22-012.

2022-11-23

Dr. Crystal Luchkiw

22-012

Motion Outcome:

Decision reserved

Details:

Jurisdictional and Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms Motion. Motions in the following matters will be heard together: Phillips, 21-023, Trozzi, 22-006, and Luchkiw, 22-012.

2022-11-21

Dr. Jamal Aboujamra

21-001

Findings:

Engaged in sexual abuse of a patient; Committed an act or omission that is disgraceful, dishonourable or unprofessional; Under appeal to the Divisional Court.

Penalty:

Under appeal to the Divisional Court.; Reprimand; Revocation

2022-11-15

Dr. Christopher Hilton Hassell

22-007

Findings:

Committed an act or omission that is disgraceful, dishonourable or unprofessional; Failed to maintain the standard of practice of the profession; Incompetence; Contravened a term, condition or limitation; Failed to respond appropriately or within a reasonable time to a written inquiry from the College; Reasons pending

Penalty:

Reasons Pending; Reprimand

2022-11-14

Dr. David Gerber

20-002

Motion Outcome:

Dismissed

Details:

Motion to participate under s. 41.1 of the Code

2022-11-10

Dr. Alexander Michael Alexander

21-024

Findings:

Committed an act or omission that is disgraceful, dishonourable or unprofessional; Failed to maintain the standard of practice of the profession; Contravened a term, condition or limitation

Penalty:

Reprimand; Suspension; Terms and Conditions

2022-11-09

Dr. Akbar Nauman Khan

20-003

Findings:

Committed an act or omission that is disgraceful, dishonourable or unprofessional; Failed to maintain the standard of practice of the profession; Incompetence

2022-11-09

Dr. David Gerber

20-002

Motion Outcome:

Granted in part

Details:

Motion for third party production and regarding scope of hearing

2022-11-04

Dr. Zoltan Peter Rona

22-005

Findings:

Committed an act or omission that is disgraceful, dishonourable or unprofessional; Failed to maintain the standard of practice of the profession; Reasons pending

Penalty:

Reasons Pending; Reprimand

2022-10-26

Dr. Ali Mohammed Abdul-Razak Al-Khafaji

22-001

Findings:

Engaged in sexual abuse of a patient; Committed an act or omission that is disgraceful, dishonourable or unprofessional

Penalty:

Reprimand; Revocation

2022-10-25

Dr. Akbar Nauman Khan

22-016

Findings:

Reinstatement Application - dismissed

Details:

Reasons on jurisdiction

2022-10-11

Dr. Awad Abdul Hadi Mortada

20-005

Findings:

Committed an act or omission that is disgraceful, dishonourable or unprofessional; Is guilty of an offence relevant to suitability to practice

Penalty:

Reprimand; Suspension; Terms and Conditions

2022-09-21

Dr. Patrick Brian Phillips

21-023

Motion Outcome:

Dismissed

Details:

Motion to adjourn hearings pending outcome of related court litigation. Motions in the following matters were heard together: Phillips, 21-023, Trozzi, 22-006, and Luchkiw, 22-012.

2022-09-21

Dr. Mark Raymond Trozzi

22-006

Motion Outcome:

Dismissed

Details:

Motion to adjourn hearings pending outcome of related court litigation. Motions in the following matters were heard together: Phillips, 21-023, Trozzi, 22-006, and Luchkiw, 22-012.

2022-09-21

Dr. Crystal S. Luchkiw

22-012

Motion Outcome:

Dismissed

Details:

Motion to adjourn hearings pending outcome of related court litigation. Motions in the following matters were heard together: Phillips, 21-023, Trozzi, 22-006, and Luchkiw, 22-012.

2022-08-25

Dr. Albert Kadri

21-010

Motion Outcome:

Dismissed

Details:

Motion for third party production and regarding scope of hearing

2022-08-15

Dr. Milad Benjamin

21-004

Motion Outcome:

Dismissed

Details:

Motions: Abuse of process & Exclusion of Evidence

2022-07-26

Dr. Jeffrey Rice Holmes Matheson

21-022

Findings:

Committed an act or omission that is disgraceful, dishonourable or unprofessional; Contravened a term, condition or limitation

Penalty:

Reprimand; Suspension; Terms and Conditions

2022-07-15

Dr. Akbar Nauman Khan

17-002-I

Findings:

Committed an act or omission that is disgraceful, dishonourable or unprofessional; Failed to maintain the standard of practice of the profession; Incompetence

Penalty:

Reprimand; Revocation

2022-07-06

Dr. Ashim Verma

21-020

Findings:

Committed an act or omission that is disgraceful, dishonourable or unprofessional; Is guilty of an offence relevant to suitability to practice; Engaged in conduct unbecoming a physician

Penalty:

Reprimand; Revocation

2022-06-30

Dr. Ayokunle Fagbemigun

19-003

Motion Outcome:

Granted in full

Details:

Motion under Rule 12.03

2022-06-13

Dr. Akbar Nauman Khan

20-003

Motion Outcome:

Dismissed

Details:

Pre-hearing motions

2022-06-08

Dr. Ayokunle Fagbemigun

19-003

Findings:

Committed an act or omission that is disgraceful, dishonourable or unprofessional; Failed to maintain the standard of practice of the profession; Under appeal to the Divisional Court.

Penalty:

Under appeal to the Divisional Court.; Reprimand; Revocation

2022-05-31

Dr. David Gerber

20-002

Motion Outcome:

Granted in full

Details:

Motion for particulars

2022-05-17

Dr. Zvi Margaliot

22-003

Findings:

Reinstatement Application - granted

2022-05-16

Dr. Syed Nasir Ali

19-001-I

Findings:

Committed an act or omission that is disgraceful, dishonourable or unprofessional; Engaged in conduct unbecoming a physician; Under appeal to the Divisional Court.

Penalty:

Under appeal to the Divisional Court.; Reprimand; Revocation

2022-04-25

Mohammad Javad Bahrgard Nikoo

21-003

Findings:

Committed an act or omission that is disgraceful, dishonourable or unprofessional; Failed to maintain the standard of practice of the profession

Penalty:

Reprimand; Suspension

2022-04-21

Jamal Aboujamra

21-001

Motion Outcome:

Dismissed

Details:

Motion for admissibility of expert evidence

2022-04-07

James Edward Roland McInnis

21-013 & 21-014

Motion Outcome:

Granted in full

Details:

Motion to Adjourn

2022-03-30

Zvi Margaliot

22-003

Findings:

Decision reserved; Reasons pending

Details:

Reinstatement Application

2022-03-28

Nikolaos Tzemos

21-019

Motion Outcome:

Dismissed

Details:

Motion for legal costs

2022-02-24

Rajeshwar Hanmiah

21-008

Findings:

Committed an act or omission that is disgraceful, dishonourable or unprofessional; Failed to maintain the standard of practice of the profession

Penalty:

Reprimand

2022-02-17

Dr. Bijan Pardis

20-006

Findings:

Committed an act or omission that is disgraceful, dishonourable or unprofessional; Failed to maintain the standard of practice of the profession; Incompetence

Penalty:

Reprimand; Revocation

Details:

Additional Finding: Acted in a conflict of interest

2022-02-09

Ashim Verma

21-020

Motion Outcome:

Dismissed

Details:

Motion for admissibility of an expert report

2022-02-03

David Lee James Wardle

21-021

Findings:

Committed an act or omission that is disgraceful, dishonourable or unprofessional

Penalty:

Reprimand; Suspension; Terms and Conditions

2022-01-28

Dr. Jeffrey Gennady Kolbasnik

21-012

Findings:

Committed an act or omission that is disgraceful, dishonourable or unprofessional; Is guilty of an offence relevant to suitability to practice

Penalty:

Reprimand; Revocation

2022-01-27

Jason Matthew Morin

21-015

Findings:

Failed to maintain the standard of practice of the profession; Reasons pending

Penalty:

Reasons Pending; Reprimand; Suspension; Terms and Conditions

2022-01-14

Mehdi Horri

21-009

Findings:

Committed professional misconduct in another jurisdiction

Penalty:

Reprimand

2022-01-07

Ken Shafquat Intikhab Abrahim

21-002

Findings:

Committed an act or omission that is disgraceful, dishonourable or unprofessional; Committed professional misconduct in another jurisdiction

Penalty:

Reprimand; Suspension; Terms and Conditions

2021-12-22

Mathieu Bélanger

19-002

Motion Outcome:

Granted in full

Details:

Motion for leave to add new evidence

2021-12-19

Dr. Harmander Singh Gill

19-004-I

Findings:

Committed an act or omission that is disgraceful, dishonourable or unprofessional

Penalty:

Reprimand; Suspension; Terms and Conditions

2021-12-16

Mory Mayer Gutman

21-007

Findings:

Committed an act or omission that is disgraceful, dishonourable or unprofessional; Failed to maintain the standard of practice of the profession; Incompetence

Penalty:

Reprimand

2021-12-07

Nikolaos Tzemos

21-019

Motion Outcome:

Granted in part

Details:

Motion for production of third-party records

2021-12-02

Harvey Stephen Pasternak

20-007-I

Findings:

Failed to maintain the standard of practice of the profession

Penalty:

Reprimand

2021-11-18

Timothy Wade Rourke

20-008

Findings:

Committed an act or omission that is disgraceful, dishonourable or unprofessional

Penalty:

Reprimand; Suspension; Terms and Conditions

2021-11-16

Nikolaos Tzemos

21-019

Motion Outcome:

Granted in part

Details:

Motion to strike portions of affidavit

2021-10-29

Luis Cesar Garcia Pan

20-001

Motion Outcome:

Dismissed

Details:

Motion to adjourn

2021-10-26

Ayokunle Fagbemigun

19-003

Motion Outcome:

Dismissed

Details:

Motion to adjourn

2021-10-18

Kenneth Buttoo

21-005-I

Motion Outcome:

Dismissed

Details:

Motion to vary

2021-10-18

Dr. John Justin Chrozy Kitakufe

21-011-I

Findings:

Reinstatement Application - dismissed

2021-09-10

Dr. Romeo Banzon Tan

18-001-I

Findings:

Engaged in sexual abuse of a patient; Committed an act or omission that is disgraceful, dishonourable or unprofessional

Penalty:

Reprimand; Revocation; Terms and Conditions

Details:

Motion made for Leave to Court of Appeal

2021-08-23

Boutros Behnam Metry Mikhail

20-004

Motion Outcome:

Dismissed

Details:

Motion to adjourn

2021-08-11

Shawn Chi Wai Seit

554636

Findings:

Committed an act or omission that is disgraceful, dishonourable or unprofessional

Penalty:

Reprimand; Suspension; Terms and Conditions

2021-07-26

Thomas Albert Botly Bell

559058

Findings:

Committed an act or omission that is disgraceful, dishonourable or unprofessional; Failed to maintain the standard of practice of the profession

Penalty:

Reprimand; Suspension; Terms and Conditions

2021-07-16

Nina Leah Desjardins

556168

Findings:

Committed an act or omission that is disgraceful, dishonourable or unprofessional; Failed to maintain the standard of practice of the profession

Penalty:

Reprimand; Suspension; Terms and Conditions

2021-06-25

Dr. Mohammed Asif Hameed Khan

553878

Findings:

Committed an act or omission that is disgraceful, dishonourable or unprofessional; Failed to maintain the standard of practice of the profession

Penalty:

Reprimand; Suspension; Terms and Conditions

2021-06-23

Fady Rizk Masoud Ghaly

531938

Findings:

Committed an act or omission that is disgraceful, dishonourable or unprofessional; Is guilty of an offence relevant to suitability to practice

Penalty:

Reprimand; Suspension; Terms and Conditions

2021-06-18

Wameed Ateyah

534469

Findings:

Committed an act or omission that is disgraceful, dishonourable or unprofessional; Failed to maintain the standard of practice of the profession; Contravened a term, condition or limitation

Penalty:

Reprimand; Suspension; Terms and Conditions

2021-06-18

Suzanne Marie Beauchemin

541975

Findings:

Committed an act or omission that is disgraceful, dishonourable or unprofessional

Penalty:

Reprimand; Suspension; Terms and Conditions

2021-06-03

William Hu

532252

Findings:

Committed an act or omission that is disgraceful, dishonourable or unprofessional

Penalty:

Reprimand; Suspension; Terms and Conditions

2021-06-02

Romeo Banzon Tan

18-001-I

Motion Outcome:

Dismissed

Details:

Motion to reopen hearing

2021-05-20

Innocent Chukwudumebi Okafor

19-005-I

Findings:

Engaged in sexual abuse of a patient; Committed an act or omission that is disgraceful, dishonourable or unprofessional

Penalty:

Reprimand; Revocation

Details:

Under appeal to the Divisional Court.

2021-05-17

Ayokunle Fagbemigun

19-003-I

Motion Outcome:

Granted in part

Details:

Motion to exclude evidence

2021-05-11

Dr. Martin Jugenburg

532006 and 540216

Findings:

Committed an act or omission that is disgraceful, dishonourable or unprofessional

Penalty:

Reprimand; Suspension; Terms and Conditions

2021-05-10

Harvey Stephen Pasternak

20-007-I

Motion Outcome:

Dismissed

Details:

Motion for non-disclosure of expert report

2021-05-07

Christopher Michael Anjema

531421

Findings:

Committed an act or omission that is disgraceful, dishonourable or unprofessional; Failed to maintain the standard of practice of the profession

Penalty:

Reprimand; Suspension; Terms and Conditions

2021-05-03

Emad Samir Luka Guirguis

532014

Findings:

Committed an act or omission that is disgraceful, dishonourable or unprofessional; Contravened a term, condition or limitation

Penalty:

Reprimand; Suspension; Terms and Conditions

2021-04-15

Dr. Neilank Kumar Jha

Findings:

Is guilty of an offence relevant to suitability to practice

Penalty:

Reprimand; Suspension

2021-04-14

Dr. John Patrick Taliano

532099

Findings:

Engaged in sexual abuse of a patient; Committed an act or omission that is disgraceful, dishonourable or unprofessional

Penalty:

Reprimand; Revocation; Terms and Conditions

2021-04-13

Harmander Singh Gill

17-001-I

Motion Outcome:

Dismissed

Details:

Motion to adjourn penalty hearing

2021-04-12

Dr. Harmander Singh Gill

17-001-I

Findings:

Committed an act or omission that is disgraceful, dishonourable or unprofessional; Failed to maintain the standard of practice of the profession; Incompetence

Penalty:

Reprimand; Revocation

Details:

Motion made for Leave to Court of Appeal

2021-04-09

Suneel Upadhye

528047

Findings:

Committed an act or omission that is disgraceful, dishonourable or unprofessional; Failed to maintain the standard of practice of the profession

Penalty:

Reprimand; Suspension; Terms and Conditions

2021-03-09

Emad Mikhail Guirguis

531716

Findings:

Committed an act or omission that is disgraceful, dishonourable or unprofessional; Contravened the Medicine Act, the Regulated Health Professions Act, 1991 or the regulations under either of those Acts

Penalty:

Reprimand

2021-03-03

James Wen Young

532304

Findings:

Committed an act or omission that is disgraceful, dishonourable or unprofessional; Failed to maintain the standard of practice of the profession

Penalty:

Reprimand; Suspension; Terms and Conditions

2021-02-26

Kenneth Werezak Adams

530176

Findings:

Committed an act or omission that is disgraceful, dishonourable or unprofessional; Failed to maintain the standard of practice of the profession

Penalty:

Reprimand; Suspension

2021-02-18

Dr. Ravi Kakar

524929

Findings:

Failed to maintain the standard of practice of the profession

Penalty:

Reprimand; Suspension

2021-02-08

Harvey Stephen Pasternak

20-007-I

Motion Outcome:

Dismissed

Details:

Motion for Production of Third-Party Records

2021-02-02

Harmander Singh Gill

17-001-I

Motion Outcome:

Granted in full

Details:

Motion to adjourn penalty hearing

2021-01-19

Leon Herman

532268

Findings:

Engaged in sexual abuse of a patient; Committed an act or omission that is disgraceful, dishonourable or unprofessional

Penalty:

Reprimand; Revocation

2021-01-18

Mathieu Bélanger

19-002-I

Motion Outcome:

Granted in part

Details:

Motion for bilingual hearing granted in part by the Discipline Committee. Application for judicial review of the Discipline Committee's decision granted by the Divisional Court on July 27, 2021.

2021-01-14

Harmander Singh Gill

19-004-I

Motion Outcome:

Dismissed

Details:

Motion to adjourn penalty hearing

2021-01-12

Harvey Stephen Pasternak

20-007-I

Motion Outcome:

Dismissed

Details:

Abuse of process motion

2021-01-05

Sheridan Reavely-Diaz

531967

Findings:

Committed an act or omission that is disgraceful, dishonourable or unprofessional; Failed to maintain the standard of practice of the profession

Penalty:

Reprimand

2021-01-04

Sammy Vaidyanathan

531628

Findings:

Committed an act or omission that is disgraceful, dishonourable or unprofessional; Failed to maintain the standard of practice of the profession

Penalty:

Reprimand; Suspension; Terms and Conditions